I watched Men in Trees on Friday night. I admit to a mild curiousity (can they really pull this off? and
will she wear carhartt's?), but mostly I thought it might be fun to blog about it. Not that I want to perpetuate the number of visits to my site by people wondering where Elmo, AK is. I'll help you guys out: Elmo, much like Cicely, does not really exist. Actually I don't think a place
like Elmo exists in all of Alaska.
Assuming the writers bothered to put much research into the show (it is evident they did not), Elmo would have to be on Prince of Wales Island. I say this because a raccoon makes an appearance on the first episode, and raccoons are an introduced species in Alaska. They only exist in a few select places, and POW Island is one of them. The candidates are narrowed down to POW Island when the radio show in Elmo receives calls from Ketchikan, a supposedly nearby town. Elmo could therefore conceivably be a town like Craig. Here we run into a problem: a bus runs daily between Elmo and Vancouver, B.C. There are no roads between this area of Southeast and the Outside. The only Southeast town with road access to the Outside is Skagway, and there are no buses that run to Vancouver daily from Skagway. I have to wonder where the writers are doing their fact checking.
Another pet peeve: casting John Boncore as George, a Tlingit character who gives Ann Heche a ride to buy cigarettes. I see that the writers had to check off their list of characters: token black man, token Native, token tough woman, token helpless woman, brooding hot white guy... I just wish they would have paid more attention to the appearance and accent of the actor they cast in this show. Tlingit people just don't have the same speech patterns as Lower 48 Natives.
OK, perhaps these things are me just being way too particular. Ken tells me that I have to learn to embrace suspension of disbelief. I do have trouble with this, and I can accept that a show might be halfway decent and really popular even when I refuse to watch it. I decided to give Men in Trees a chance. I thought I might even watch a second episode, just for kicks, until Anne Heche falls through the ice and is rescued by brooding hot white guy, James Tupper.
I can deal with the heroine in distress rescued by knight in shining armour aspect. Sort of. Then Anne has to take all of her frozen wet clothes off to get warm and subsequently falls asleep naked with James because there isn't any heat or fire, and this is the only way to get warm. Okaaayyy... I can deal. HOWEVER, when the camera pans to the outside of the cabin and Anne's clothes laid out on the roof to dry out, I swear I will never watch this show again if Anne can put her clothes back on in the morning. No heat source, including hardly any sun, and freezing temperatures mean Anne's clothes should be a solid block of ice and too stiff to slip into.
Suffice to say I'm never watching the show again.
Couple that with the following reviews:
The title, "Men in Trees," is seen on a warning sign meant to alert people below that pruning and trimming are going on above. "Beware 'Men in Trees' " would be even more appropriate. Please consider yourself warned.
and...
How nice to know there's nothing wrong with a woman that can't be cured by a week in the wilderness.
Unless that idea strikes you as anything other than total throwback nonsense, you may have a hard time hurdling past the setup of ABC's Northern Exposure wannabe, Men in Trees... you have to be willing to believe in an Alaska that is on another planet rather than a distant corner of the continent.
Is it really so hard to run plot lines, casting, and maybe one episode past a real Alaskan? I think this could have potentially saved the show. Of course we aren't the target audience. No wonder tourists love main street Skagway.